What If the Colorado Shooter
Had Been Using Marijuana Instead Of A Pharmaceutical?
Two Different Standards.
(Marijuananews note: First, the toxicology
reports on the Colorado shooters came back negative for alcohol and other drugs. That fact
was buried inside a few stories. Can you imagine the headlines if there had been a
hemi-semi-demi-nanogram of cannabis metabolite in either of them?
See
Family
Research Council Issues A (Misleading) Correction, But No Apology.
However, there is very restrained consideration being given to the fact that one of them
had been taking a cousin of Prozac, called Luvox.
I have no knowledge of -- or opinion about this drug.
However, I think that it is interesting to see how the standards for marijuana are very
different from those for any other drug.
One thing that this column does not tell us and it should have is that
none of these drugs are tested on children, even though many drugs, notably Ritalin,
affect children very differently from adults.
Of course, we can only wonder if he would have benefited from medical marijuana, but
consider again the different reaction that that suggestion would receive.)
April 30, 1999
From the Washington Post
http://washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/edit/letters/letterform.htm
http://www.washingtonpost.com/
By Avram Goldstein
(Marijuananews note: Avram Goldstein is a professor emeritus of
pharmacology at Stanford University and was a member of the Review Committee of the IOM
Medical Marijuana Report. The Post didnt mention that, but they dont like
talking about medical marijuana.)
See
Former Head Of
NIDA Sort of Calls For Medical Marijuana Tests in Washington Post Op-ed.
Taking Care Of the Prohibitionist Party Line. Not the Patients.
SHOOTER USED OFTEN PRESCRIBED DRUG
The psychiatric drug that Eric Harris had been taking before he went on a shooting
rampage at a Colorado high school last week was prescribed about 1.4 million times last
year to people suffering from obsessive-compulsive disorder and associated depression.
Luvox, which is in the same pharmacological category as the
widely used depression drugs Prozac, Zoloft and Paxil, is praised by health professionals
as an important tool in the treatment of the inherited disorder.
They agree that while Luvox is not a perfect solution, it does help rein in the
recurrent and irrational thoughts, impulses or images that interfere with the lives of an
estimated 5 million Americans, including many children. Some children as young as 5 are
given such drugs.
The maker of the drug, Solvay Pharmaceuticals, said 6.9 million patients of all ages
worldwide have used the drug, which increases the brains ability to use a
message-carrying chemical called serotonin.
Although suicide attempts are listed as a possible adverse
reaction in consumer information distributed with the drug, government officials, private
practitioners and the manufacturer said yesterday that such episodes are rare and likely
to be caused by the underlying depression that led the patient to Luvox.
"Its considered a good and safe drug," said Judith Rapaport, chief of
child psychiatry at the National Institute of Mental Health in Bethesda and a longtime
researcher on obsessive-compulsive disorder. "There is no reason to think it would
have any relationship to any unusual or violent behavior."
Jerry L. Rushton, a University of North Carolina pediatrician who studies serotonin
drugs, said patients who stop taking them typically experience
withdrawal problems, including increased agitation and anxiety. Some reports say Harris
had tried to stop taking Luvox after he was rejected by the Marine Corps because he was on
the drug.
(Marijuananews note: If that is true, then wasn't he going through withdrawal?)
See
New NIDA Sponsored
"Latest Research" Shows Competitiveness of Heavy Marijuana Users
Not Impaired When They Stop Smoking Well, That Is My Interpretation
2 Versions From Reuters
However, Food and Drug Administration officials said that they have seen no evidence
linking Luvox to violence and that its performance has so far been clinically acceptable. "We see hundreds of people using this family of medications," said
Charles Mansueto, a psychologist who directs the Behavior Therapy Center in Silver Spring
and provides counseling to clients taking drugs prescribed by psychiatrists.
"Im not aware of any particular problem with Luvox."
(Marijuananews note: Excuse me, but isnt that anecdotal
evidence? There are many thousands of medical marijuana users, but the fact that they very
obviously stop vomiting, or writhing in pain, etc., is dismissed as anecdotal. Meanwhile,
can the much harder to measure psychological effects of Lovax be inferred from clinical
observations of the sort that are not acceptable for medical marijuana?)
One Washington parent said yesterday that when her 12-year-old daughter, who has the
disorder, stopped taking Luvox for two days recently, she began having thoughts about
suicide. The situation was remedied immediately after she resumed taking the drug, the
mother said. The mother, who did not want to be named, called it "an absolute miracle
drug."
See
Transcript of
Politically Incorrect May 15th, 1998 With Todd McCormick; Introducing
Iatrogenic Suicide
Doctors and patients said it is unfair to associate obsessive-compulsive patients with
an increased tendency toward suicide or violence. If anything, the nature of their often
bizarre symptoms makes that less likely, they said.
"People with [the disorder] are by definition aware of their irrational obsessions
and virtually never act on those obsessions," said Thomas H. Styron, a clinical
psychologist and executive director of the
Obsessive-Compulsive Foundation in Milford, Conn. "While their impulses are scary
and anxiety-provoking, they are not reality based and virtually never acted on."
In the 12 months ending in February, Solvay Pharmaceuticals sold $145 million worth of
the drug.
Luvox has increasingly been prescribed to adolescents. Some
critics say that more clinical trials on children are needed and that some physicians
should raise the threshold for prescribing such drugs.
A Fairfax County high school senior who has suffered from the disorder since she was 7
struggled with various drugs until she began taking Luvox in a clinical trial in 1989,
said her father, who did not want to be identified. The improvement was dramatic, he said,
and she never had any side effects or thoughts of violence or suicide.
Copyright: 1999 The Washington Post Company
|