New NIDA Sponsored
"Latest Research" Shows Competitiveness of Heavy Marijuana Users
Not Impaired When They Stop Smoking Well, That Is My Interpretation
2 Versions From Reuters
(Marijuananews note: Yes, it is
the old "Latest Research" game by the National Institute on Drug Abuse.
See
LATEST
RESEARCH Finds That Heavy Marijuana Smoking
Produces Pre-Cancerous Conditions; Save The Children!
and
McCaffrey
Says Rather Than Focus On Individual Drugs, The Drug Culture Should Be Targeted.
"The problem isnt the kind of drug; its drug-crazed, stoned
behavior." And It Gets Weirder...
Released on 4/20 just to show that they have a sense of humor?
Perhaps because of the tragedy in Colorado, or perhaps because it is
just so damned silly, this is not getting any press coverage. Nonetheless, it will become
a part of the prohibitionist propaganda about how marijuana
This is an extraordinary example of a waste of tax money to prove
something pointless. I have not yet seen the study, but my headline was as deliberately
tendentious as theirs.
In our culture "aggressiveness" is bad, but
"competitiveness" is good. I think that my interpretation is as valid as the
authors but I am not after NIDA funding.
After all these years, they will sponsor a test with as little real world relevance
as this one, and then interpret the results in this way proves only that NIDA is desperate
to prove that marijuana is "addictive." Notice that in the first version from
Reuters, one of the authors even "emphasized that the new results do not suggest that
heavy marijuana users would be aggressive outside the laboratory setting."
I have not seen the full text of the study yet, so this is all that I know.
Here are two versions of the same story with different spins and a few different
facts.)
Pot smokers aggressive when quitting
April 20, 1999
NEW YORK, Apr 20 (Reuters Health) -- People who have smoked marijuana daily for many
years display more aggression when they are going through
withdrawal than do infrequent and former users, according to study results
reported by researchers at Harvard University in Boston, Massachusetts.
The study is "further evidence that a withdrawal syndrome is
associated with abstinence from long-term marijuana use," according to a statement
issued by the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), which funded the study.
"People addicted to marijuana may continue to use the drug at least partly to
prevent the onset of withdrawal symptoms," said NIDA Director Dr. Alan I. Leshner in
a statement. "Identifying the exact nature of this syndrome is crucial to developing
treatment strategies for those attempting to stop their marijuana use."
(Marijuananews note: Leshner is prohibitionisms little joke on
the scientific community. Notice that there is no other consequence of cessation reported.
Try that with really addictive drugs.)
See
Marijuana Is
Addictive; The Internet Is Addictive; Therefore This Site Is A Hard Drug
-- New Study
and
The
Scientist Magazine Does A Reverent Interview with the Head of NIDA
and links
NIDA reports that marijuana "is the most widely used illicit drug in the United
States." According to the 1997 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse, more than 11
million Americans used marijuana in the past month.
The Harvard researchers studied the behavior of 17 long-term heavy users of marijuana
and 20 people who were infrequent or former smokers. The subjects were placed in a chamber
facing a computer monitor and a response panel that had two buttons, labeled A and B. They were told that they would compete against another subject in a
separate chamber, although they were actually responding solely to the computer.
If the person pressed the A button 100 times, he or she gained 1 point, while pressing
the B button 10 times subtracted points from the opponent. The subjects participated in
five sessions, scheduled during marijuana use in the case of current users, and after days
1, 3, 7 and 28 of abstinence.
Current marijuana users became significantly more aggressive 3 and 7 days after
withdrawal, compared with those who were infrequent or former marijuana users, according
to the NIDA.
The lead investigator, Dr. Elena Kouri of Harvard Medical School in Boston,
Massachusetts, told Reuters Health that the computer test has been used in a number of
studies to measure aggressive responses to other substances.
She emphasized that the new results do not suggest that
heavy marijuana users would be aggressive outside the laboratory setting.
The study findings are published in the April issue of the journal Psychopharmacology.
SOURCE: Psychopharmacology April 1999.
April 20, 1999
Study Finds Quitting Marijuana Can Cause Withdrawal
(Marijuananews note: Notice the different spin. This takes "withdrawal" as
proven, when it actually is only a possible inference.)
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - People who smoke marijuana every day become
more aggressive when they quit, adding to evidence that users can go through withdrawal,
U.S. researchers said Tuesday.
Dr. Elena Kouri and colleagues at Harvard University said they had shown objectively
that when people stop smoking "pot," there is a clear withdrawal syndrome.
"This syndrome, although less dramatic than the withdrawal syndrome associated
with alcohol, opiate or cocaine withdrawal, may contribute to relapse among those
dependent on marijuana," Dr. Alan Leshner, head of the National Institute of Drug
Abuse (NIDA), which funded the study, said in a statement.
"People addicted to marijuana may continue to use the drug at least partly to
prevent the onset of withdrawal symptoms."
But finding out why this happens may help researchers come up with better treatments
for users, he said.
See
Australian
Study Of Very Heavy Cannabis Users
Shows Most Can Quit With 16 Weeks of Counseling
and links
Writing in the journal Psychopharmacology, Kouris team said they used a computer
test that pitted 17 long-term heavy users of marijuana against 20 infrequent or former
smokers. The volunteers did not know that aggressive behavior was being studied.
They were told that pressing a button labeled "A" 100 times would win them
one point, worth 50 cents. Pressing a button labeled "B" 10 times would take a
point away from an imaginary opponent of the same sex who was supposedly sitting in
another cubicle.
The computer beeped to show that the "opponent" was taking a point away from
the volunteer.
The tests were given over a period of 28 days, during which the users did not smoke
marijuana. The heaviest users became significantly more aggressive
during the first week, an indication that they were going through withdrawal.
"Most of the studies that have been published on marijuana withdrawal symptoms in
people have relied on self-report," Kouri said. Users have reported feeling
irritable, but this was the first test to verify this objectively, she said.
According to the National Household Survey on Drug Abuse, published in 1997, more than
11 million people had smoked marijuana in the one-month period that the survey was done,
making it the most widely used illegal drug.
"Although it is difficult to be certain of the exact
prevalence of cannabis addiction in the United States, I can tell you anecdotally that we
had no difficulty recruiting dozens of people between the ages of 30 and 55 who have
smoked marijuana at least 5,000 times," Dr. Harrison Pope, who led the study,
said.
(Marijuananews note: The fact that people have done something numerous times does not
mean that they are "addicted." However, we might infer that marijuana is even
more widely used than the official estimates say.
Pope was one of the authors of one of the most deliberately misleading studies on the
effects of marijuana on intellectual performance. )
See
Prime Time Live's
"Junior High" Journalism
|