From MSNBCMarch 21, 1998
World@MSNBC.com
http://www.msnbc.com/
MARIJUANA BOOK SPARKS DEBATE
New York
Its the exact opposite advice one would expect from a
parent, doctor or teacher about smoking marijuana.
However, a new book by two city
university professors concludes that smoking marijuana is not harmful, and doesnt
make users, including college-aged students, unmotivated.
Columbia University Medical School Professor John P. Morgan, M.D. said, "Marijuana
has some dangers but the dangers that young people have been told for a decade are not
true."
Claiming the book,
Marijuana
Myths, Marijuana Facts, is scientifically sound, Prof. Morgan
and co-author Lynn Zimmer, Ph.D., a sociology professor at Queens College, write,
"Even long-term high-dose marijuana use is not harmful to the brain. Marijuana use
during pregnancy does not damage the fetus. There is nothing about marijuana that causes
people to lose drive and ambition. Marijuana does not cause crime."
The American Medical Association criticizes the book, saying it minimizes the real or
potential dangers of marijuana.
(Ed. note: No, a book review in the JAMA was mildly critical of some parts, but see
See JAMA Book Review: Marijuana Myths, Marijuana
Facts -- "Extraordinarily Well-Researched And Passionately Argued" )
"The drug comes to the brain, binds itself to the brain, exerts its affect and
leaves and probably causes no long-term damage," Prof. Zimmer said. "Theres no evidence that occasional use impairs people ability
to be good people, good parents, good citizens, productive workers."
But on that, and the issue of marijuana and crime, the book was denounced by long time
narcotics officer turned New York City Police Commissioner Howard Safir.
"Theres no doubt marijuana leads to trouble and I can show you 10 books that
prove that for every one like the one you just showed me," he said. (Ed. note: I think that the Commissioner may be taking the term
"weight of the argument a bit too literally. Nor is "how the evidence stacks up
measured with a tape measure.) "The fact that these two
professors are teachers leads me to wonder if they are fit to be leading a
classroom."
However, Prof. Zimmer maintained, "I think most people use marijuana in a
responsible way."
The authors said the book would not have been possible without city universitys
help. It was researched at taxpayers expense. Prof. Zimmer was granted a years
sabbatical with pay and given an award from the presidents office, an additional six
months to work on the book.
Required by law, all CUNY students are told in writing about
the health risks of illicit drugs and sanctions for using them. However, some of that
information directly contradicts data in this new book, which could potentially lead to
confusion on the campus about marijuana and its true effects.
(Ed. note: Yes, telling students the truth would confuse the hell out of
them; they are so used to be lied to.)