Learning Important Lessons from Bad
Journalism in Article Supposedly About Hemp
Submitted By John E. Dvorak, Hempologist &
Managing Editor, Hemp Magazine
>This story could be told in one or two lines:
"New Hampshire House Narrowly Defeats Hemp Cultivation Bill. Republicans Question
Motives of Sierra Club." However, this article demonstrates several other
points that anyone interested in the cannabis controversies needs to keep in mind.
Lets walk through it. My thanks to John Dvorak for bringing it to my attention.
See
Good Motives, Bad Journalism, Hemp Cultivation and
"The Drug Culture" Revealed in A Readers Complaint From
THE CONCORD MONITOR
"Material posted to this site retains copyright. See the
Users Guide for details."
(Ed. note: This is a copyrighted story. This means that the media
get to keep control of their propaganda. Stories like this are like small drops of poison
that leave no trace. There are so many of them, but they do their work and
disappear.)
Hemp Bill Backers, Like, Bummed Out House Defeats Commercial
Growing Measure
(Note the mocking tone starts with the headline. Recently, I received an email from a
college student expressing concern that this issue is never discussed seriously, and until
it is, we will never make progress. Wise beyond his years. Say "marijuana" and
everyone giggles or snickers. The implicit message is "You cant be
serious!" This is the greatest challenge that we face. Many people who agree with us
do not take the issue really seriously. "It's only marijuana!"
Last year, when the huge Bay Area Kaiser Permanente HMO reported the results of the
largest long-term study of marijuana users, over 65,000, ever undertaken, the UPI story on
it ran under the headline "One Toke Over the Line." This had absolutely nothing
to do with the content of the story. Oh, you didnt hear about the report? Well, that
could be because it was not reported in any of the major media outside of California.
However, marijuana use had no impact on life expectancy or rates of illness. Alcohol and
tobacco use does. Isnt that funny! One toke over the line! )
Friday, February 13, 1998
By JIM GRAHAM
Monitor staff
Dude! The hemp bill went up in smoke at the State House
yesterday.
You know, like, the hemp bill, dude? The one that would have allowed New Hampshire
farmers to grow commercial hemp - the kind you absolutely, positively could never ever get
a buzz off? It looks like the real stuff, but smoking it wouldnt give you anything
more than a downer of a headache.
Anyway, the House trashed it, 175-164. Close, but no bone - ah, make that cigar.
Supporters were way bummed.
(Wow, like do you suppose like I could like uh go to like journalism school? Oddly, at
this point the reporter starts to do his job.)
"I am not supporting a marijuana bill. I am supporting a hemp bill," said
Rep. Peter Leishman, a Milford Republican.
He and other backers said the battle for hemp isnt about drugs, but is about
educating the public on its potential value to farmers and industries.
Hemp bears only a passing resemblance to its illegal cousin, has no potential for abuse
and, they said, it is grown around the world to make such mundane items as rope, cloth,
paper, plastics and even building materials.
"I have a backpack made of hemp," Leishman said, wearing a hemp vest and
holding up what looked like an ordinary canvas knapsack. "Probably very difficult to
smoke and you would probably get a heck of a headache if you did."
New Hampshire would have become the first state in the nation to legalize industrial
hemp.
Opponents, however, werent buying any of it.
The said the hemp bill is part of a gradual, not-so-subtle nationwide movement to
legalize hemps illegal cousin.
"Who do they think theyre kidding? . . . I dont believe for a
millisecond that this is just a commercial hemp-related bill," said Rep. Kathleen
Flora, a Bedford Republican. (Ed. note: Presumably, she then went
off to give a speech on the evils of big government and the importance of freedom to a
group of disabled Vietnam veterans who are medical marijuana users. When they try to talk
to her about that, she has her staff send them a form letter about her support for the
D.A.R.E. program.)
Under the bill, the state would have controlled distribution of the hemp seed, and
farmers would have needed a permit to grow it. Hemp-made materials
are already allowed for sale in the state, and the crop is legally grown in 23 countries,
including Canada and throughout Europe. An estimated 100,000 acres were grown in the
United States during World War II to supply fiber for ropes and cloth.
But Rep. Robert Boyce, an Alton Republican, also doubted the
motives of hemp supporters. "This bill is about marijuana no matter what the
proponents call it," he said. "Voting for this bill is a vote to legalize
marijuana." (Ed. note: Most of the prohibitionist
arguments today are about "motives." There are three things fundamentally wrong
with this. First, it is irrelevant. It does not address the merits of the arguments.
Second, it ignores the fact that many of the proponents of hemp and or medical cannabis
have no interest in legalizing marijuana or may even oppose it. Finally, if motives are to
be discussed, what are the motives of the opponents of hemp and medical marijuana?)
Hemp, however, could help small farmers looking for a cash crop that doesnt
require herbicides, pesticides or heavy fertilizers, said Rep. Derek Owen, a Hopkinton
Democrat.
And for those worried that growers could hide marijuana plants in with their hemp
crops, Owen tried to put their fears to rest: When the plants cross-pollinate, hemp
dominates and destroys marijuanas ability to produce illegal, mind-altering
chemicals. He said the plants somewhat similar appearance should not be an issue.
"No one confuses water with vodka, even though they look the same," Owen
said.
The New Hampshire Sierra Club supported the bill, saying hemp
could reduce logging pressure in the states forests by providing a cheap source of
pulp for paper, building materials, alternative fuels and even food. (Ed. note: The support of the Sierra Club is very important to the future
of the hemp issue.)
"The bill will be back next year, and the New Hampshire Sierra Club will see that
our elected representatives understand why hemp is good for New Hampshires families
and for our common future," said Tom Elliot of the Sierra Club.
(Jim Graham can be reached at 224-5301, ext. 313, or by e-mail at jgraham@cmonitor.com.)
ABOUT John E. Dvorak. John is an eight year resident of
Allston/Brighton, MA, and is the proprietor of the Boston Hemp Co-op and Managing Editor
of Hemp Magazine. He is a member of the Hemp Industries Association, the International
Hemp Association, and Mass/Cann NORML. He can be reached at 617-254-HEMP and boston.hemp@pobox.com.
=-=-=-=-=-
Hemp Magazine
Advertising & subscription info:
Richard Tomcala, Publisher
hempmag@lconn.com
713-523-3199
Hemp news & writers wanted!
Contact John E. Dvorak, Managing Editor
boston.hemp@pobox.com
617-254-HEMP
|