Laughter And Tears At Gil
Puders Memorial Service:
"The Stash Is In The Freezer."
Plus 2 Articles.
November 19, 1999
See
Gil Puder, R. I. P.
A Great Loss For The Anti-Prohibitionist Movement,
An Even Greater Loss For Canadian Law Enforcement.(Marijuananews
note: It has been a long time since I have been in a place with so many cops. But this was
a church.
This afternoon I took my good friend Hilary Black of the BC Compassion Club to the
memorial service for Gil Puder. Hilary feels as though the Vancouver medical marijuana
community has lost a champion and a hero.
See
Canadian Medical
Association Journal Carries Favorable Article On Vancouver Compassion Club
But there were both tears and laughter.
The laughter came when Gils brother recalled how -- many years ago -- he had
complied with Gils instructions to tell the truth when he was interviewed by a
senior Vancouver police officer about Gils application to join the force.
While Gil was out, the officer came to the apartment the brothers shared to ask the
"usual questions." The last question was whether or not Gil had used marijuana.
"Yes," the brother truthfully replied. "And the stash is in the
freezer." The stunned officer simply responded by suggesting that they should get rid
of it, because they were going to be giving Gil a job offer.
Everyone in the church laughed, including the many uniformed police officers. They
laughed even more when the brother explained that they got rid of the stash by making
cookies for their college basketball team.
This anecdote and the laughter offer a remarkable insight into both Gil
Puders character and the reality of marijuana prohibition in Vancouver.
First, Gil told always the truth. Second, many of the police valued that, even as the
politicians in and out of uniform resented him for it. To their vast credit,
there were many Vancouver police there today, and their grief was genuine.
Gil is gone, but his spirit, the spirit of truth, will never die.
Shortly before he died, Gil wrote the Op-ed below for the
Seattle Post-Intelligencer. As the accompanying note explains, a book he had just finished
will be published next year.)
November 7, 1999
From The Seattle Post-Intelligencer
editpage@seattle-pi.com
http://www.seattle-pi.com/
By Gil Puder, Special To The Post-Intelligencer
Note: The author is a decorated 18-year veteran of the Vancouver, B.C.,
Police Department. His book, "Crossfire: A Street Cop's Stand
Against Violence, Corruption and the War on Drugs," is scheduled for publication by
Douglas and McIntyre next year.
THERE'S MORE TO DRUGS THAN 'JUST SAY NO'
The Republican governor of New Mexico, Gary Johnson, recently made an astounding public
statement. He said America's war on drugs is a multibillion-dollar failure, that it has unjustifiably jailed thousands of people while lying about the
dangers of marijuana, and that many illegal drugs should be legalized and strictly
regulated.
See
New Mexico Governor
Speaks To Anti-Prohibitionist Student Group:
"Then you do marijuana for the first time, and it's not so bad.
It's kind of cool. That's when kids find out it's been a lie.''
Johnson is now the highest-ranking elected official in the United States to say, in
effect, "The emperor has no clothes."
I've spent my career in law enforcement, and I believe Johnson is absolutely right.
In 1984 an armed heroin addict robbed a bank. I fired a fatal round that cost that man his
life. Two years later, another junkie with a gun took the life of my friend, Sgt. Larry
Young. More recently, I had to tell a woman that her son had died from a drug overdose.
The experience was devastating -- not only for her, but for me, as well. I don't dislike
the drug problem; I hate it.
Yet, while the governments of both our countries spend billions of our tax dollars every
year fighting the so-called war on drugs, the shameful truth is, it hasn't worked. It
never will. I don't want to lose another friend or bring more mothers the same bad news.
It's time
for all of us to wake up.
When I deliver this message to local business leaders at Seattle
Downtown Rotary Club's luncheon on Nov. 17, I expect many to be apprehensive.
(Marijuananews note: Sadly, he never made it.)
But perhaps the need for a change in policy will begin to sink in when my co-speaker,
Dr. Alonzo Plough, director of Public Health-Seattle and King County, outlines the
increasing gravity of the situation.
With some 10,000 addicts, King County has one of the worst heroin problems in America, and
it's getting worse. Last year, according to data compiled by the state Division of
Alcoholism and Drug Abuse, more people died in King County from heroin-involved overdoses
than died in motor vehicle crashes.
Who am I to be talking about your problems? Someone who recognizes we've got plenty of our
own in Canada. In my city, Vancouver, B.C., residents are dying from drug overdoses at the
rate of about four a week. An injection-drug HIV epidemic has drawn international
attention to our neighborhood known as the Downtown Eastside. I know that good neighbors
should tend to their own problems first, but this is a common problem, and I believe good
friends should look for shared solutions.
Your neighborhoods and mine are under siege. Being a street cop, witnessing the tragedy
firsthand, I've become convinced that drug prohibition -- not drugs themselves -- are
driving the HIV epidemic and the systemic crime that has swamped our criminal justice
systems.
Unfortunately, this is nearly impossible to admit if you're a politician who built your
"law and order" image by vilifying drugs and demonizing addicts as the epitome
of moral decay.
Yet "rabid junkie" stereotypes are seldom reality -- certainly not the housewife
addicted to prescription painkillers or the 14-year-old boy shot at a Vancouver-area high
school.
People who have heavily invested in the status quo chant mantras of zero tolerance
mandatory minimum sentences while both the supply and demand for drugs increases and jails
burst at the seams. For 80 years, we've waged the war on drugs with a central focus
criminal sanctions. Anyone who thinks we're winning has their eyes closed, or simply
doesn't want to see.
I know there's no silver bullet for this monster, but there are more effective solutions.
First, we must accept reality: Drugs, including alcohol and tobacco, are here today. Not
all drug users are abusers, and not all abusers become addicts. Once we acknowledge these
fundamental truths, the responsible approach for dealing with drugs becomes clear -- shift
some of our resources away from interdiction and punishment toward treatment and
education.
Next, we must understand that drug addiction is, above all, a medical and public health
issue. Like alcoholism, it is a form of disease that an be successfully treated to reduce
harm to society.
Crime must be punished; violent crime and crimes against children must be punished
severely. But we could dramatically reduce drug-related crime and its horrendous human and
financial costs by decriminalizing and strictly regulating drug use.
The benefits of such reform would be immediate. Windfall savings on criminal justice
dollars could be plowed into health care and rehabilitation, which are the only methods
proven to correct substance abuse.
Not every drug should be treated the same. The sale or
distribution to children, as well as trafficking, importation and exporting, should remain
crimes, with perhaps even stronger penalties. By focusing law enforcement on these areas,
police efforts might actually make a difference.
Finally, the messages we send our children should be based on facts,
loving concern and useful guidance, and not on fear, threats and propaganda.
Watching a televised documentary on drug abuse, including
disturbing images of a man killed by his father, my 9-year-old son listened to addicts
explain the disorder ruining their lives. Not once did he ask his father, the cop, why
these criminals weren't in jail.
His advice to me was, "Dad, these people are sick." Untainted by a lifetime of
misinformation, our kids understand this problem better than many adults.
(Marijuananews note: Gils son was at the memorial service.)
This is the message we should be sending: Drug abuse is unhealthy and wrong. We can't stop
adults from getting drugs -- we only fooled ourselves in thinking that we could. We'll
teach you how devastating drugs can be. If you make the wrong choice, we'll help you make
better ones. But if you choose to use drugs, we will not allow you to harm others, or to
make them available to children, and we'll punish you severely if you do so.
That's a message that makes a lot more sense than "just say no." And, it's a
message our children are far more likely to believe.
Copyright: 1999 Seattle Post-Intelligencer.
November 16, 1999
From The Vancouver Sun
sunletters@pacpress.southam.ca
http://www.vancouversun.com/
PUDER Gilbert William Harold. July 11th, 1959- November 12th, 1999.
With heavy hearts we are saddened to announce our loss of Gil. Gil had 17 years of
distinguished service in the Vancouver Police Department. He was also an instructor at the
Justice Institute of BC/Police Academy, and at
Langara College Criminal Justice Department. Gil was a dedicated athlete.
He played and coached basketball for the University of British Columbia Thunderbirds; he
was a black belt in Canada Shotokan Karate participating in many local and international
tournaments; and he actively participated
in youth sports, coaching both basketball and soccer.
He was an accomplished writer who regularly contributed to professional publications
related to policing issues of Control Tactics/Physical Training, Use of Force and most
recently Gil was a well known advocate for Drug Law Reform. He is survived by his wife
Christine, sons Jason and Brendan; his mother Barbara, father Richard; brothers Randy and
Jeremy (Freda), nephew Austen; Uncle Gary (Eileen), cousins Susan and Jay;
grandparents Georgia and William Rickson; and many friends and colleagues.
Gil had diverse interests and talents; he touched many lives and will be remembered for
his strong beliefs and commitment to action. He always loved a healthy debate.
A memorial service will be held on Friday November 19 at 2:00pm at
Ryerson United Church, 2195 W. 45th, Vancouver. Donations in Gil's honour may be made to
the BC Cancer Agency or the Canadian Cancer Society BC/Yukon Division.
Copyright: The Vancouver Sun 1999