If marijuana has medical value, why isn't medically
available in the Netherlands?
This question was raised
most recently by Gabriel Nahas on the editorial page of The Wall Street Journal and by the
Drug Czar in the Washington Post. The short answer is that marijuana
is medically available in the Netherlands. There are doctors who prescribe it
without any hindrance from the government, and their patients can either grow their own or
take their prescriptions to certain coffee shops and get their marijuana at a substantial
discount. The most important point is that someone in the Netherlands who has a medical
condition that responds to marijuana does not have to live in fear of being arrested, nor
does the physician who discusses it with the patient and prescribes marijuana for medical
use.
The longer answer is that a Dutch commission recently did a very brief
overview of the subject of medical marijuana and decided that there was not sufficient
evidence of the medical efficacy of marijuana to include it in the national health
insurance so patients could be reimbursed for their purchasing marijuana. Moreover,
Dutch medical regulations make no provision for herbal medicines, unlike German and some
other European regulations.
While the results of this review were disappointing from the
anti-prohibitionist perspective, the matter is far from settled. It may be hard to fathom,
but Dutch doctors seem to know less than many American doctors about the medical uses of
marijuana. If one wrongly thinks of the Dutch as being "pro-marijuana," then
this ruling could be misunderstood, but the fact is that Dutch doctors are a very
conservative bunch, as are the Dutch people in general. It is one thing to tolerate
something, it is quite something else to have it reimbursed by the national health
insurance.
In any case, the question before the Dutch doctors was not whether sick
people should be arrested for using marijuana. If you were to ask a Dutch doctor that
question, the reaction would be emphatically negative.