Disabled California
Veteran Who Told Police He Was Growing Medical Marijuana
To Sue Them For Arresting Him
(Ed. note: This could be a
very important case. Certainly it shows that the police in most areas are not interested
in acting in good faith and obeying state law. Suing them is often the only way to get
their attention.)From the Los Angeles Times
By Coll Metcalfe, Times Staff Writer
June 2, 1998
letters@latimes.com
http://www.latimes.com/
PATIENT MAY SUE POLICE FOR POT ARREST
Law: Military veteran with doctors prescription for medical marijuana says he was
within his Prop. 215 rights in growing cannabis plants for own use.
SIMI VALLEYThe latest test of Californias medical marijuana law is shaping
up in Simi Valley, where a man arrested last month for cultivating more than a dozen pot
plants said he will sue police for violating his rights as a patient.
Dean Jones, 62, made the announcement Monday at his lawyers office in Thousand
Oaks, saying he will file suit against the department and one of the arresting officers
for violating the protections of Proposition 215, a 1996 initiative approved by 56% of
voters statewide.
"Im just a patient trying to get medication," Jones said. "I
believe that I did everything right according to the law."
Police, however, say officers conducted themselves properly and are confident that if
the case is filed and goes to court, they will be vindicated.
"We dont, by any stretch of the imagination, believe that we violated Mr.
Jones rights," said Lt. Neal Rein of the Simi Valley Police Department. "I think that the fact that he was even arrested says a lot about the
case."
Jones, a military veteran who said he incurred leg, back and head injuries during a
training exercise, said he suffers from constant migraine headaches, diabetes, high blood
pressure and periodic foot inflammation.
He has also been diagnosed with skin cancer and, as recently as last week, underwent
surgery to have lesions removed from his face and neck.
In addition to a card identifying him as a patient eligible to
receive the drug, he has a prescription from his longtime doctor for marijuana to aid his
treatment regimen.
Jones, a marijuana user for more than 20 years, said he began growing the drug about
four months ago after the Cannabis Club in Thousand Oaks was closed by the Ventura County
Sheriffs Department.
Worried that people could spot his potted marijuana plants in his backyard and get the
wrong impression, Jones and his 82-year-old wife went to the police
station May 26 and informed officers what he was doing.
"I thought it was the right thing to do, telling them that I was growing cannabis
at my home as medication," he said. "But since I did that, its all gone
downhill."
The next day, two officers went to his home. After Jones invited them in to see his
plants, the officers arrested Jones and took him to Ventura County Jail, where he was
booked on suspicion of felony marijuana cultivation.
He was released about 12 hours later on his own recognizance and will be arraigned
Wednesday at the Ventura County Courthouse.
Although the practicalities of Proposition 215 are still being interpreted by the
courts, the initiatives wording states that criminal statutes
"shall not apply to a patient, or to patients primary caregiver, who possesses
or cultivates marijuana for the personal medical purposes of the patient upon the written
or oral recommendation or approval of a physician."
See Text Of Proposition 215
Despite Jones prescription and official card that identifies him a user of
medicinal marijuana, authorities maintain that in this instance he does not qualify for
the exemption.
"There are a lot of questionable issues involved with this particular case and one
of those deals with quantity," Rein said. "The law allows for personal use and
we understand that, but, again, there are some questions in that regard."
Jones attorney, Stanley Arky, also represents Andrea Nagy, who opened the
countys first cannabis buyers club in Thousand Oaks last year. He accused
police of flouting the law.
"If you cant grow your own and you cant purchase it, how is law
enforcement enforcing Prop. 215?" Arky asked rhetorically.
If the case is brought to court, it may provide another test of a law that already has
proved to be particularly prickly.
Authorities, for instance, are caught between conflicting state and federal laws
regarding possession, use and cultivation of marijuana.
Stating that under carefully prescribed circumstances marijuana is legal, Proposition
215 contrasts sharply with federal laws that classify the drug as dangerous and prescribe
stiff penalties for possession, use and cultivation.
"Some laws are pretty cut and dried, but this one is open for interpretation and
that has led to some of the confusion and cloudiness," said Rein, of the Simi Valley
police. "All of these cases now fall into that gray area, so we have to take them one
at a time."
Most recently, the issue of medicinal use of marijuana has focused on buyers
clubs like the ones in San Francisco and the one that operated in Thousand Oaks until
authorities closed it in February.
The issues in those cases revolved around the legality of selling a controlled
substance to qualified patients publicly out of storefronts.
Unlike these disputes, the Jones case goes to the very heart of Proposition 215: What
protections do qualified patients have to grow their own marijuana?
For Arky, the answer is clear.
"What we have here is a patient who was arrested after he went to the police to
inform them in an effort to comply with the law. . . . What we need to keep in perspective
is that he is a patient who has been denied treatment."
|