The 50th
Anniversary of The Publishing Of Orwells 1984
Analysis By Richard Cowan
June 7, 1999 Yesterday was the 50th anniversary of the
publishing of 1984. That this date passed with so little notice might be taken as a
warning of how badly we have failed to understand some of its authors major points.
Even though the term "Orwellian" has become a part of the language, it is
generally applied to only one of the dangers government surveillance -- against
which he was warning. Ironically this was the one point on which he was most nearly
wrong.
1984, in keeping with the tenor of the time 1948 -- in which it was
written, is an overwhelmingly pessimistic book. However, as much as Big Brother would love
to watch us all, that has proved impossible, and technology has also made it relatively
easier for us to watch Big Brother. This error by Orwell was not just technological.
Orwell (Eric Blair) like so many other anti-Communists -- overestimated the
ability of governments to control the people, and even more importantly
underestimated the drive for individual freedom.
The fall of Communism probably would have surprised Orwell, but other developments
would not have. In the other major themes of 1984, Orwell was much more nearly
right, and -- sadly -- is much less understood.
To the citizens of the London of 1984, "the chief city of Airstrip
One," the most salient fact of life was endless war. The enemies kept changing, but
the war never stopped. Today, DEAland, for good reasons and/or bad, stays involved in
conflicts around the world, but these conflicts do not have much relevance in the daily
lives of the people. They really cannot serve the purpose that war served in 1984.
There is one war, however, that touches everyone, and is designed never to end. That is
the Drug War, the soul of which is the war on marijuana.
See
Ten More Years; Six Million More Arrests, Says Czar
Too Long; Too Few, Says Newt.
Actually, the Czar Did Not Mention the Arrests, but No One Ever Does.
It gives the government of DEAland an excuse to interfere in the internal affairs of
every country, not just those that are actually threatening DEAlands real interests.
See
Drug Czar Uses Foreign
Affairs Magazine Article For Anti-Dutch Propaganda,
Elevating The Lying To Official Status. Analysis By Richard Cowan
and
The
"Vietnamization" of the Drug War; US Narco-Imperialism Goes In Search of
Enemies
The Quagmire of Tomorrow
It also gives the government of DEAland an excuse to interfere in the private lives of
everyone, because anyone could be a marijuana user. The huge number of marijuana users,
and the fact that most are indistinguishable from non-users, makes everyone a suspect.
See
Everyone Is A Suspect At
US/Canadian Border As Customs Searches For Marijuana --
Another Cost of Prohibition
This is the perfect pretext for creating a police state.
See
Prohibition Provides
Practice For A Police State In Wisconsin:
"5 counties involved in still-secretive highway safety initiative."
In 1984 everyone was constantly reminded that "Big Brother Is Watching
You." Today, such a statement would be offensive, in large part thanks to Orwell.
Instead, people are being encouraged or rather frightened into wanting Big
Brother to watch them. How is this being done? Through fear and hatred.
I think that the most important feature of 1984 is "Newspeak" and
"Doulblethink." Orwell even wrote an Appendix to 1984, "The
Principles of Newspeak."
As Orwell explained, the purpose of Newspeak was not just to provide a medium of
expression, but to make "heretical thought
.literally unthinkable."
"To give a single example. The word free still existed in Newspeak, but it
could only be used in such statements as This dog is free of lice or
This field is free of weeds. It could not be used in the old sense of
politically free or intellectually free, since political and
intellectual freedom no longer existed even as concepts, and were therefore of necessity
nameless." Pages 246 and 247.
Obviously, this limiting of the use of the word "free" reminds me of the
current obsession with being "free of drugs" and the so-called "Partnership
for A Drug-Free America.
I do not think that there has ever been a single institution that has posed a threat to
individual freedom of Americans comparable to that posed by the Partnership.
See
When The Partnership
For A Marijuana-Free America Speaks,
The Media For A Marijuana-Free America Parrots.
Widely Reported Press Release About Kids and "Drugs" Mentions Marijuana 29
Times, Alcohol 0!
and
Magazine Publishers
of America Agree To Feature Prohibitionist Propaganda In Content
To Get Share of $775 Million Ad Campaign
At one level, the Partnership is simply a collaboration of the worst of opportunistic
businessmen in the mass marketing industry and government propagandists. They really do
not want a "drug-free" America,
See
Deadly
Drug Sold by Founder of Partnership for A Drug-Free America, Says Forbes
and the methods they employ are cynical in the extreme.
However, the Partnership is by no means the prime mover here. It is rather an
opportunistic infection that has taken advantage of a long-term decline in our ability to
think critically. Orwell was very concerned about the loss of meaning, which he did not
blame on any conspiracy.
See
"The
governments relationships to the media industry, and to the public, are
changing."
and
Hundreds Of
Newspaper Editors Try To Figure Out What To Do About Readers Distrust (Hint: Stop
Lying!)
It is this decline in intellectual standards that makes a culture and society
susceptible to propaganda. After all, Hitler rose to power at a time that Germany was
politically and culturally very vulnerable. The reasons for Germanys problems are
easily understood at this point, while the reasons why we are having such difficulty
dealing with basic concepts is less clear.
The danger from The Partnership is that it has brought a high level of sophistication to
creating a new ideology that is limiting the definition of freedom as was Newspeak.
Their job is to eliminate the competition from marijuana for their patrons in the
alcohol and pharmaceutical industries. However, this can only be done by eliminating our
ability to think critically about "drugs." They have a great advantage in that
this idea seems absurd to most observers in spite of the overwhelming evidence.
However, this can now be seen in their bitter opposition to including warnings about
alcohol in their prohibitionist propaganda.
See
Mothers Against
Drunk Driving Denounce Partnership For A Marijuana-Free America
For Opposing Warnings About Alcohol -- PR Disaster For Pharmaceutical Lobby Grows
If the Partnership and its allies in the government and the media were merely waging
war on cannabis, that would be bad enough, but they are also waging war on the very
meaning of words and on our ability to use them to communicate.
See
"Mom, Dad, What are Drugs?"
One of the inescapable features of life in 1984 was the "Two Minute
Hate" during which everyone was required to focus on hating the enemies of Big
Brother.
See
"These
legalizers put American children at risk.
The Dutch government should be renouncing them, not siding with them."
What? Oh, Never mind!
and
Swedish
Prohibitionists Denounce Body Shop And Anita Roddick:
"Demands for legalisation of cannabis is not an example of moral, ethical and social
responsibility.
On the contrary, it shows a clear lack of moral, ethical and social responsibility."
In 1999 DEAland we have the omnipresent anti-marijuana prohibitionist propaganda provided
by the Partnership and the government. Today it is most visible in ads that ask, "Are
you waiting for your kids to ask you about pot?"
See
Page On The Drug
Czars Web SiteProjectknow.ComIs Called "True Lies" And It
Truly Is
There are two consequences of this.
The first is a fanatical commitment to marijuana prohibition by certain types of
ideologues. Such people were also characters in 1984. Marijuana prohibition has
become the backbone of the prohibitionist ideology that drives such diverse groups as the
police, the "treatment" industry, the "drug testing" industry, and
above all others, the "drug education" industry. The latter are ideologues, pure
and simple. They have nothing else to offer.
See
How Marijuana
Prohibition Corrupts All Of Our Institutions
Medicine, Law Enforcement, Journalism
And How That Corruption Sustains Prohibitionism
They are the vectors for the second consequence of the emphasis on anti-marijuana
propaganda -- a disastrous undermining of all substance abuse education.
See
They Are Legal, So They Must Be Safe:
"Teens Abusing Drugstore Medicines"
Should We Have Drug-Free Drugstores?
Context For Medical Marijuana and "Drug Education" Debates
The fact that anti-marijuana prohibitionist propaganda inevitably encourages substance
abuse will ultimately destroy marijuana prohibition. In the meantime it has the ironic
effect of benefiting marijuana prohibition, because it is not recognized as being counterproductive.
As is typical of statist ideologies, the fact that things are getting worse is used to
justify more of the same.
Even many of the critics of drug prohibition dont understand that it is counterproductive.
They think that prohibition is merely a failure. They do not understand that it has
exacerbated the problem that it was intended to solve. Consequently, they approach reform
very timidly, afraid that ending prohibition will make the "drug problem" worse.
This inability to grasp the concept of marijuana prohibition as counterproductive is an
example of the failure of critical thinking caused by our own Doublethink.
"Doublethink means the power of holding two contradictory beliefs in ones
mind simultaneously, and accepting both of them."
These anti-prohibitionists actually hold two contradictory ideas at the same time.
Marijuana prohibition is both a worthy cause and a failure. There are people who are so
convinced that drug prohibition is a failure that they favor the legalization of drugs
generally, but they still look with disdain on the users of marijuana and the supporters
of medical marijuana and hemp. It is all rather beneath them.
Also there are people who have decided that some aspects of marijuana prohibition are
failures and favor just medical marijuana or hemp. They have been conditioned to think
that the people who agree with them are bad and the people who have been lying to them for
decades are really good.
See
THE HEMP CASINO, HEMP WHORLED, & ROPERS VS.
DOPERS
By John E. Dvorak, Hempologist
and
American Farm Bureau
Convention Narrowly Votes Against Researching Hemp Production
In part, this misplaced respect is the result of decades of the Two-Minute-Hate. If
someone has been conditioned to hate the enemies of Big Brother it is very difficult to
stop hating them and admit that they were right all along. It is easier just to decide
that Big Brothers noble experiment was just a sad failure.
Even prohibitionists play this game. The Drug Czar, alias Big Brothers Little
Helper, is now declaring that the Drug War isnt really a war. There wont be
any change in policy. The violence will continue. He just wants to stop calling it a war.
When he makes this statement it is never questioned by the media.
See
From The Drug Czars 8-Year
Plan to the Republicans Drug-Free Century Act,
The Prohibitionist Agenda Is War Without End. Orwell Would Understand.
Analysis By Richard Cowan
1984 was not just a warning about the dangers of totalitarian governments.
Indeed that was only one part. The most important part is the need for critical thinking
and a commitment to the meaning of words as a part of that process.
As Orwell demonstrated, when we lose the ability to think for ourselves, freedom really
will be lost.
The one great technology that he did not foresee, the Internet, must be the means by
which we maintain not only a commitment to truth and freedom, but to the tools of critical
thinking that will enable us to regain our freedom and preserve it forever.
See
Online Lobbying Killed A
Banking Regulation; Is This The Political Future?
A Brilliant Column By Alan Bock
"After the Internet, democracy will never be the same."
and
Australia, New Zealand,
Sweden, The International Prohibitionist Counterattack,
and How We Can Use The Internet
and
Medical
Marijuana and the Internet